Tracking v Bushcraft

By Pablo | Posted in tracking
September 19th, 2007

When I was following some deer at the weekend, I reflected on whether there were any differences between bushcraft and tracking philosophies. It might appear on the surface that tracking and bushcraft go hand in hand. They both involve closeness with the natural environment and an element of wilderness living. Well they do go hand in hand but only to a certain extent. This isn’t the law according to Pablo and it’s not even a law per se, but I’ve kind of deduced there are some fundamental differences in philosophies when comparing the two (apart from the obvious activity of looking at tracks.)

The average bushcrafter (and I appreciate that there are those that fall outside the norm) will carry enough kit to be comfortable. That’s what bushcraft is about – being comfortable in the natural environment. Generally a large tarp is carried; a hammock or tent, sleeping bag and perhaps a folding chair. Lamps, bright torches and cooksets are not out of place. I’ve seen more and more tipis being used and also larger camp fire utilities (cast iron Dutch ovens, fire boxes) and provisions that would feed an army not to mention liquid refreshment of the alcoholic nature in quantities that Nelson would be proud of. I would probably say that all this results in the appearance of a semi-permanent if not permanent camp. Nothing wrong with that of course, but you can imagine all that’s missing is the quick erection of a log-cabin and you have a Kephart hunting lodge.

Trackers would probably go much lighter. Of course there may be a base camp, but when actively tracking it’s a different matter. After all, modern tracking is descended from the most ancient of skills – hunting; and hunters tend to go light. Also you couldn’t just stop tracking and set up your 6 foot high tipi and slice up your side of venison on the dot of 6 pm when you’re in the middle of tracking an animal. Nor could you carry about a 60 pound Bergen for mile after mile while being out-sensed, out-manoeuvred and out-witted by deer. You rest when you can, sleep when you can (which is very little it seems) forage on the move and only when it’s convenient to the animal you’re tracking – not you. You would also only completely stop when you’ve achieved your aim. Just how this works in practice, I really haven’t got a clue, but it will be an interesting exercise to find out. There’s no doubt that all the bushcraft skills that I’ve learnt (and many more I’ve yet still to learn) will come right to the fore.

I’ve also thought there might be a number of differences in kit. A Tracker’s kit may appear to be more technical. This may well be to do with weight and space saving and definitely “function over form” instead of vice versa. Craft products, possibly an integral part of bushcraft, appears a little out of place, while the tracker might use all modern equipment at their disposal.

There are a number things I have to do if I am to look at tracking more seriously:

Firstly, I have to cut down on kit. Like everyone else (it appears) I aspire to travel as lightly as possible but this will now be a necessity. Next, I will have to learn to sleep and rest even closer to the environment than I have done previously. This will avoid detection (I guess) and increase awareness. It will probably mean a return to ground dwelling or at least dispense with all the elaborate trappings of a normal Bushcraft setup. It will also probably mean improving skills at natural shelter building and possibly back to digging scrapes and holes (Oh what joy!). I will also have to learn how to keep on the move and how to forage while keeping on the move with no more than a quick stop.

Is this a daunting prospect? You bet your a**e, but an exciting one!

Pablo.

Tags:

3 Responses to "Tracking v Bushcraft"

  1. Jon says:

    Hi Pablo

    It sounds like you are ready for one of Max’s Scout courses! As a tracker you do have keep it light if you are to ‘run on the spoor’. we do use base camps though :) .

    Jon

  2. billy says:

    “After all, modern tracking is descended from the most ancient of skills – hunting; and hunters tend to go light.”

    Of course they do, and their women carried everything else.
    For lightweight hunting/tracking you should surely study Nessmuk rather than Kephart, and if you carry a tarp you have no need to ‘consruct’ a shelter beyond stringing the tarp.

  3. Anonymous says:

    Hi Mr P great blog as usual, I have been away on some well earned R&R but is was good to get back and catch up. I found your interpretation of Bushcraft V Tracking v.intresting and just had to reply! I think these 2 philosophies are the same! If you go back to our bushcraft roots our ancestors were hunter-gatherers, they would have a base camp, hunt the local area maybe spend the odd night away then come back with the next weeks supply of meat, hoping the women folk had done some gathering! when the herds moved on or they started having blank days they would up sticks and move. On the days away all they would carry is their weapons and a means to light fire, everything else they needed was in their heads which weighed nothing! all the add on’s, pots pans fuel etc etc came later as we developed. So my friend don’t be to hard on yourself with the amount of kit you have, this will be refined each time you go out and you will soon know what is really needed and what is just nice to have! to cheer you up I have aquired over the years 5 stoves and yet the quickest to boil a pint of water is the kelly kettle 3-4min depending on the wind!If you would like to chat further please feel free to contact me at c.newton@poole.gov.uk
    Regards
    Sailor

Leave a Reply

Woodlife News

Next Hatfield Course

Woodlife Trails

The next Countryside and Woodland Awareness Course at Hatfield Forest with places still available is Sun 11th March.

Bushcraft Magazine

Bushcraft Mag

Pablo's article The Urban Fox is the cover article in this month's Bushcraft and Survival Mag available from 23 December.

Courses Slideshow

Jp's Twitter

Archives

Woodlife Trails Ltd

Woodlife Trails

Registered in England and Wales at Companies House.

Company Registration Number: 7931032

Registered Office:

Headley House, 16A Orsett Road, Grays Essex, RM17 5DL

info@woodlife.co.uk

Search

About us

About UsWelcome. This is the home of Woodlife. You will find links to Pablos Woodlife (blog) the Woodlife Social Network (forum) and Woodlife Trails (courses) all on this page.
Theme Tweaker by Unreal