Project Number One - EKA Nordic W11 Knife
reviews, tools November 9th, 2008If you ask people who practice bushcraft or wilderness living what is the most essential item in their kit and they will invariably answer that it’s their knife. Many people go to great lengths to select their knife and usually only a custom knife will do. Of course, selecting a knife is very much a personal preference and it depends on what you’re going to use it for.
For me, the jury’s still out. I’m not sure if I’m 100% happy with a single knife (see updated cutting tools pages). Perhaps I’m the sort of person to select whatever tool or combination is right for the occasion.
I still haven’t committed myself to an expensive custom knife and enjoy experimenting with the odd knife that comes my way. My latest addition to the family is an EKA Nordic W11. Ironically, this was the first knife I was going to purchase after my very first Frost’s Clipper; but I decided to go for Phil Siddell’s Companion Mark 2 instead. When I saw the EKA on Ebay, I decided to go for it, winning the auction at just £47-50. They normally retail around £20 or £30 more (£68-00 Edit £83-00 from Heinnie Haynes)
The EKA Nordic Hunter W11 is Swedish made 8 7/8in. overall with a 4 3/8 inch drop point blade. It’s a full-length tang Sandvik 12C27 57-59 Rc out of 4mm with checkered Bubinga wood scales and lanyard hole.
I liked the shape of the knife from the start. Perhaps a 4mm thick 4 inch “all rounder” blade would, after all, be the most suitable general purpose knife for me. The reviews have been favourable and as a factory-made knife it’s often compared to the Falkniven F1. The reviews threw up a few problems though, which prevented me from buying it in the first place. The first was the bevel and the second, the sheath.
When I received the knife I was delighted to notice that EKA had listened to feedback and had changed the sheath. Previous owners were bemoaning the fact that no matter how careful they were, the knife always cut the sheath when pulling out or putting away the knife. This must be a brand new version. Also it was obvious the knife has never been used. Chuffed.
Unfortunately the deep hollow grind with secondary bevel was still there. I’d read that this could be rectified with a little re-profiling and I was convinced that could do it! Of course, I’d do it my way, and not the recommended way with mouse mat and wet and dry. Out came the diamond hones and before long I was scrubbing away with the black coarse re-profiling hone throwing all caution to the wind. The aim was to extend the secondary bevel and then make it slightly convex…sort of! Not an easy task when you’re leg is elevated in a plaster and you’re using an upturned tea tray as a work-bench!
Quite a few hours later (actually many, many hours later) I had increased the original bevel size and there appeared to be a slight convex shape to the blade. I now worked my way down the hones to sharpen the edge, finishing off with a good strop.
Now I’m certainly not an expert and I’ll have to give it a proper knife guru for them to tell me I’ve completely ruined it! Nevertheless it’s now razor sharp and it looks ok to me. Whether it will stand up to a “bushcraft bashing” is another story, and of course, I won’t be able to give a go for a few weeks yet.
The knife feels great in the hand. It has a nice weight to it, but not over heavy like some custom 4mm’s I’ve handled (including the Woodlore). It fits my hand extremely well (I’ve got small hands) and I like the forefinger cut out and the serrated thumb grip on the spine. The handle is warm and I like the light checkered serrations on the lower part of the handle. Not bad so far.
As for performance, I can’t say any more at the moment.
Needless to say, I enjoyed doing this little re-profiling task. Project Number One - done and dusted…Next!
Thanks for the visit,
Pablo.



November 10th, 2008 at 4:24 am
Looks like it will make a fine knife, I use a Cold Steel Master Hunter with a Carbon V blade after trying several I settled on it because it fits my needs at least for the moment.
Keep us up to speed on how your new knife works out might just have to give one a try.
November 10th, 2008 at 11:51 pm
Hi Pablo,
Just passing by, after watching your knife safety video on YouTube. Great work, you may have saved quite a few people from cutting themselves this way. Sorry to hear about your own accident, hope you’ll ecover soon.
P.S. the F1 has got a convex grind from the factory, but I must admit: the wood on the EKA is beautiful, better looking even than the expensive micarta F1
I got the F1 and still like it, and it looks like you got a great deal as well.
I’d like to think that purchases made on impulse reflect our personality better than those rational buys that carry mathematical proof but lack the emotional component that’s required in order to stay attached to something for years on end, even if it isn’t working properly :). Take care, Hans.
November 11th, 2008 at 7:55 am
Michael - Thanks. I’ll let you know how it works out.
Hans - I never thought of it in that way. Good point.
November 11th, 2008 at 10:46 am
Just like you I’d been eyeing the W11 for quite some time and only fairly recently decided to get it, although with the old sheath. I didn’t even know there was a new sheath out there! I’ll have to see how I do with avoiding cutting the sheath to pieces. It’s a shame it’s got this fault, as I think it looks gorgeous and (for the eye) fits extremely well with the knife.
I too have small hands, and can only agree on the handle lying very well indeed in the hand. I believe EKA has found a very good design there, and would personally love to see it on other knives as well.
Regarding the factory grind - Well, I’m not too keen on it either, and have also been playing with the idea of reshaping it. However, being sharpening challenged, I still haven’t managed to gather enough courage to actually get on with it and do the reshaping. Your article gives me a bit faith though, and brings me a bit closer to trying it.
Say, did I understand it correctly that you did it all by hand, or do you work with a jig of some sorts?
How many hours did you actually have to spend on the reprofiling?
November 11th, 2008 at 12:53 pm
Karl - I spent in total about 6 hours reprofiling it by hand. Please don’t follow my example, because I’m not sure if I did a good job or not! Looks ok though
Have a look here to see how the experts do it. http://www.britishblades.com/forums/showthread.php?t=4390
November 11th, 2008 at 4:48 pm
Aw’right, thanks Pablo!
That BB link showed me how to do things.
Need to go get some abrasive paper now.
November 11th, 2008 at 5:41 pm
Pablo
Your SO right - it’s not a collection - its a family!
I really like the finger indent, i’ve had the situation where the blade has gripped and the handle has slipped, and that little bit extra grip is reasureing.
Good to hear that you putting your time on your back to good use. get well soon
SBW
November 11th, 2008 at 11:26 pm
Looks lovely!.. and kept you busy for a good while! It reminds me of nerve-racking times that I have tried the same thing, I too am no expert but have reprofiled blades by hand, it really can take a long time!.. I now have a great range of waterstones so I could do it quick than my first attempt. I might be wrong but did you get the Heinnie Haynes price wrong in your post? You’ve got it as £68 it looks like £83.95 to me on their site? All the best, Ashley Cawley.
November 27th, 2008 at 8:02 pm
Nice review Pablo, These knives look pretty good, I like the smooth handles with the checker, but as you say, the grind is not for bushcraft grind. I love 12c27 steel, it with RWL-34 is the only Stainless steel I use in my own stuff.
Well done, glad you like it.
P.S. Anytime you want anything reprofiled or reground and you don’t want to, give me a shout!
November 28th, 2008 at 12:35 am
Really nice look to the knife. I use a blade I bought from Brisa.fi, which I made my own handle for. It’s good, a Puuko-style, but I regret buying a six-inch model. The more wandering around I do, the more I appreciate a smaller blade. Hey ho. So now I’ve bought a little three incher from Attleborough Accessories and fitted it to a little lump of oak I rescued from the log pile. And it’s a beauty!